The Fine Line Between True Crime and Exploitation

Famous YouTuber Stephanie Soo is one of the leading YouTubers in true-crime content, known for her detailed storytelling and in-depth analysis of cases. Image Credit via Youtube

True crime has always been a genre that has captivated its audience, whether it was through gripping documentaries, sensationalized news reports, or compelling podcasts. Over the years, it has turned into an increasingly popular form of entertainment. Content creators – especially Youtubers – have picked up on this trend, basing their content on raising awareness for these cases that would otherwise go unnoticed. While these creators provide insightful analysis, it raises the question: How far can true crime content go before it crosses the line from respectful storytelling to exploitation?

As YouTube became the leading platform for true crime content, it further complicated the issue of ethical dilemma. Creators had to face the delicate task of respecting the lives of victims while providing engaging content and entertainment for their viewers, ultimately in an attempt to gain subscribers. Content creators like popular YouTuber Stephanie Soo strive to avoid the sensationalism that often accompanies true crime stories. Through meticulous research, she unravels mysteries, explores motives, and sometimes even discusses controversial aspects of the justice system. Her goal is to stay mindful of the impact her work may have on the families involved.

Despite these intentions, it’s hard to ignore the reality of these content creators monetizing tragedy. With videos raking in millions of views and often generating significant ad revenue, no matter the intention, victims and their families are reduced to objects of entertainment.

It is also important to note that the true crime genre has gained an impressive number of fans. Since August 24, 2024, 54% of America’s population consumes true crime content daily. It’s not uncommon to hear the sentence, “I love true crime” or even “I’m obsessed with true crime, I need to know more.” No one blinks an eye when someone says this. Today’s society views the genre as just another form of entertainment without fully understanding that these cases involve real-life people and real victims who are left scarred for the rest of their lives.

The obsession with true crime may never fade. It’s a genre that easily captivates its audience and leaves them wanting more. But it’s time that society reevaluates its obsession with true crime. Content creators and people alike must stay mindful of the human stories behind the headlines. True crime enthusiasts must ask themselves if they are truly supporting the content out of curiosity or out of a deeper, more unsettling fascination for tragedy.